An Open Letter Calling for an Official Explanation, Accountability, and a Formal Apology.
By Ali Yousefi, Ph.D., RCIC-IRB
Founder & CEO, Elegant Immigration Services
RCIC-IRB Licence R535117
November 1, 2026 · North Vancouver, British Columbia
نسخه فارسی این مقاله را بخوانید (Read in Persian)
Introduction
On October 26 and 27, 2026, Prime Minister Mark Carney received His Highness Sheikh Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi, in Ottawa. The visit was presented to Canadians as an economic and strategic milestone. One day later, on October 28, 2026, the Office of the Prime Minister published a joint statement that, in its closing section, took a position on one of the most sensitive territorial questions in the Middle East: the status of Abu Musa, Greater Tunb and Lesser Tunb, three islands in the Persian Gulf.
I write this commentary as a Canadian, as an Iranian Canadian, and as a practitioner who works every day within Canada’s legal system. I am not writing on behalf of any government, regulator or court. I am writing because I believe this declaration was unnecessary, unexplained, and deeply hurtful to millions of Iranians, including the many Iranian Canadians who are part of this country’s fabric. I respectfully but firmly call on Prime Minister Carney to explain it, to reconsider it, and to apologize to the Iranian people.
1. What happened in Ottawa: the verified facts
According to the Prime Minister’s own news release of October 27, 2026, the visit was the first-ever visit to Canada by a Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi. During the meeting, the two leaders launched a new Canada–UAE Strategic Partnership and signed a Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA), whose negotiations were concluded in 47 days. The release also describes a Memorandum of Understanding on Defence Cooperation, a diplomatic-training MOU between Global Affairs Canada and the Anwar Gargash Diplomatic Academy, the launch of negotiations toward an extradition treaty and a mutual legal assistance treaty, and progress on the UAE’s commitment, announced in November 2025, to invest $70 billion in Canada.
These are significant economic and security commitments. Canada is entitled to pursue them, and I do not dispute the value of trade, investment and partnership with the countries of the Gulf.
2. What the joint statement says about the three islands
The joint statement published on October 28, 2026 covers trade, investment, defence, energy, technology, water, polar research, agriculture, international cooperation, people-to-people ties and tolerance. Its final section, titled “Sovereignty and international law,” begins with general commitments to the Charter of the United Nations, respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, non-interference, and the peaceful resolution of disputes. It then states:
“In this respect, they called for an end to the occupation of the three islands of the UAE, Greater Tunb, Lesser Tunb, and Abu Musa, which constitutes a violation of the sovereignty of the UAE and principles of the Charter of the United Nations.”
In plain terms, through this joint statement the Government of Canada has associated itself with three propositions: that the islands belong to the United Arab Emirates; that their present administration is an “occupation”; and that this situation violates the UN Charter.
For accuracy, I note what the official record does and does not show. The position appears in a written joint statement issued by the two governments. I am not aware of any oral declaration by Prime Minister Carney on this subject, and I do not suggest that any economic agreement was exchanged for this language. My objection is to the text the Government of Canada chose to publish under the Prime Minister’s name.
3. A contested question, not a settled one
The sovereignty of Abu Musa and the two Tunbs is a long-standing dispute. Iran has administered the islands since 1971 and regards them as an integral part of its territory, citing historical title. The United Arab Emirates claims them and has repeatedly called for their return or for the matter to be referred to negotiation or international adjudication. No international court or tribunal has ruled on the question.
That is precisely the point. When a dispute is unresolved, the ordinary and prudent diplomatic practice for a third country is to encourage peaceful settlement without pre-judging the outcome. The joint statement does more than encourage settlement: it adopts one party’s characterization of the facts, including the legally loaded word “occupation,” and declares a breach of the UN Charter.
4. Why I object to this declaration
First, it is unexplained. The statement contains no indication of the legal or historical basis on which Canada has concluded that the islands belong to the UAE, that they are “occupied,” or that the UN Charter has been violated. Canadians are given a conclusion without reasons.
Second, it was unnecessary. The visit’s stated purpose was economic and strategic cooperation. Nothing in the trade agreement, the investment framework or the defence MOU required Canada to take sides in a territorial dispute between two other states. Including this language, in my view, reflects a serious error of diplomatic judgment.
Third, it sits uneasily with the statement’s own principles. The same section speaks of “the peaceful resolution of disputes.” Declaring one side to be in breach of the UN Charter, before any impartial body has examined the claims, is difficult to reconcile with that commitment.
Fourth, the words matter. “Occupation” is a term with specific consequences in international law. A Canadian government statement should not deploy it in a contested matter without clear, public and reasoned justification.
These are my legal and political objections. They are not judicial findings, and I do not present them as such. They are the reasoned concerns of a Canadian who believes his government owes the public an explanation.
5. Foreign policy authority and democratic accountability
The Government of Canada has the constitutional authority to conduct foreign affairs and to adopt positions on international questions. I do not dispute that authority. But authority and accountability are not opposites; in a parliamentary democracy, they go together. When the government takes a position that departs from careful neutrality on a contested sovereignty dispute, Canadians are entitled to know why, on what legal basis, after what consultation, and with what consideration of the effects on Canadian communities.
6. Iran’s territorial integrity and the Iranian people
For me, and for very many Iranians at home and abroad, the Persian Gulf islands are not an abstraction. They are part of a national identity shared across political, religious and generational divides. Respect for Iran’s territorial integrity is not a partisan position; it is one of the few things on which Iranians of almost every viewpoint agree.
It is essential to draw a clear distinction. Criticism of the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran, its human-rights record, or its conduct in the region is legitimate, and many Iranian Canadians share that criticism deeply. But the Iranian nation is not the same as the Islamic Republic. Governments change; nations and their territory endure. Opposition to a regime must never become a reason to disregard the historical and territorial sensibilities of the Iranian people themselves.
7. The concerns of Iranian Canadians
Canada is home to one of the largest Iranian diaspora communities in the world. Iranian Canadians are doctors, engineers, lawyers, entrepreneurs, students, workers and public servants. Many of them came to Canada precisely because they valued its commitment to fairness, the rule of law and respectful dialogue. For this community, seeing the Government of Canada describe part of Iran as “occupied” territory, without explanation, has been painful and confusing. It sends the message that their history and identity were treated as a bargaining detail in a broader economic relationship. Whether or not that was the intention, the effect is real, and it deserves a response.
A Formal Request to Prime Minister Mark Carney
Prime Minister Carney, I respectfully and formally request that you and your government:
- Explain publicly why language concerning Abu Musa, Greater Tunb and Lesser Tunb was included in the October 28, 2026 joint statement with the United Arab Emirates.
- Disclose the legal and historical basis on which the Government of Canada concluded that the islands are “the three islands of the UAE,” that they are under “occupation,” and that this constitutes a violation of the Charter of the United Nations.
- Reconsider this position and return to Canada’s appropriate role of encouraging the peaceful resolution of the dispute without pre-judging its outcome.
- Apologize formally to the Iranian people, including Iranian Canadians, for a declaration that disregarded their deeply held national and historical connection to these islands.
Prime Minister Carney, apologize to the Iranian people. A clear explanation and a sincere apology would strengthen, not weaken, Canada’s credibility as a country that respects international law, values its diverse communities, and holds itself accountable for its words.
Conclusion
Canada can build strong economic ties with the United Arab Emirates without taking sides in a territorial dispute with Iran. Canada can criticize the Islamic Republic without disregarding the Iranian nation. And a democratic government can correct a mistake without loss of dignity. I hope the Prime Minister will do so.
Official sources
- Prime Minister of Canada, Joint Statement by Prime Minister Mark Carney and His Highness Sheikh Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi (October 28, 2026), section “Sovereignty and international law.”
- Prime Minister of Canada, Prime Minister Carney launches new Strategic Partnership with the UAE, welcoming landmark trade agreement and billions in investment (October 27, 2026).
About the author: Ali Yousefi, Ph.D., RCIC-IRB, is the Founder and CEO of Elegant Immigration Services in North Vancouver, British Columbia, and a Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant (Licence R535117).
Disclaimer: This commentary represents the personal views of the author. It is not legal advice, and it does not represent the position of the College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants (CICC), any other professional regulator, any court or tribunal, or any Canadian governmental institution. No regulator or professional body has endorsed these views. Quotations from official documents are taken from the Prime Minister of Canada’s website as published on the dates indicated.


Recent Comments